
Quick summary
- Fits shoppers who want a spacious used electric crossover on the Supercharger network and can live with a firm ride.
- Look elsewhere if a hushed cabin, real buttons or smartphone mirroring matter more to you than range per dollar.
- Pick the rear-drive Long Range: it carries the top EPA rating in the lineup and uses the least energy per mile.
Short answer: the 2025 Model Y is the final year of the original 2020 design, not the redesigned car. Testers praise its range, room and charging access, and fault its stiff ride and cut-rate cabin finish. The refreshed Model Y that many 2025 reviews describe is registered in the US as a 2026 model. Bought used, a Long Range RWD with its recall work done is the sensible choice.
Is the 2025 Model Y the new design?
No, and it is the most useful thing to know before reading any 2025 Model Y review. Tesla says it began North American deliveries of the redesigned car, the one with a light bar across the nose, nicknamed Juniper, in March 2025. In the United States those cars carry the 2026 model year. The federal records show it plainly: NHTSA logged a recall for 2026 Model Ys on 30 May 2025, and the EPA’s 2025 Model Y ratings, added to its database in December 2024, are the outgoing car’s numbers, while the redesign’s ratings sit under 2026.
So a 2025 Model Y is the car Tesla had sold since 2020, in its last year: three versions, the familiar shape, and the firm ride reviewers kept flagging. The mix-up is everywhere. J.D. Power’s page for the 2025 Model Y, for example, puts owner survey results for the old car next to a preview article that calls the redesign the 2025 model. If a listing or a review shows a light strip running the full width of the nose, it is describing a 2026.
2025 Model Y pros and cons
What works
- Range for the money: the Long Range RWD is EPA-rated at 337 miles, and even the Performance clears 275.
- Efficiency: 125 MPGe combined, or about 27 kWh per 100 miles, for the rear-drive car.
- Space: Tesla quotes 76 cubic feet of total cargo space, front trunk included, and the Long Range AWD could be ordered with a small third row.
- Charging: Supercharger access at up to 250 kW, which Tesla says adds up to 170 miles in 15 minutes on the RWD car.
- Crash ratings: five stars overall from NHTSA and a Top Safety Pick+ from the IIHS.
What doesn’t
- Ride: both magazines we read, and owners surveyed by J.D. Power, single out a firm, jittery ride.
- Highway range: at a steady 75 mph, Car and Driver got 220 miles from a Long Range AWD, against the 311-mile EPA rating of the 2025 car.
- Cabin finish: build quality, interior materials and the sound of the doors closing all draw complaints.
- Controls: almost everything runs through the 15-inch touchscreen, and there is no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.
- Timing: the 2026 redesign is quieter and goes further on the same battery energy, which caps what a 2025 is worth.
What do reviewers and owners say?
Car and Driver scores the 2025 Model Y 7.5 out of 10. It credits the car with quick acceleration in most versions, big range estimates and generous space in the front two rows, then marks it down for build quality, a stripped-back cabin that will not suit everyone and a third row too tight for adults. Range, in its view, is the Model Y’s strongest card, yet at this money other electric SUVs appeal to the magazine more. Its own testing is the sobering part: 220 miles from a Long Range AWD and 230 from a Performance at a steady 75 mph, with the AWD car averaging 94 MPGe on the highway loop.
MotorTrend ran a Model Y for a year and came away unimpressed with how it drives: a harsh ride, abrupt throttle response and a cabin that drones on rough surfaces. It does like the storage, the phone app and the stereo, it timed a Long Range AWD at 4.4 seconds to 60 mph, and its advice is to pass on a 2025 unless the deal is too good to refuse.
Owners tell a similar story. J.D. Power’s survey of 2025 Model Y owners after 90 days has them happiest with motor power, the setup process and navigation, and least happy with interior material quality, door-closing sound and ride comfort. That lines up almost point for point with what the professional testers found.
2025 Model Y specs by trim
Tesla’s spec sheet lists no horsepower, so the motor row below shows the ratings in the EPA’s records instead. Range, efficiency and home-charging time are EPA figures; acceleration (with rollout subtracted), weight and Supercharger speed are Tesla’s, from its Model Y page as it stood in November 2024.
| Long Range RWD | Long Range AWD | Performance AWD | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motors (EPA record) | one, 221 kW | two, 91 kW and 183 kW | two, 135 kW and 200 kW |
| EPA range | 337 miles | 311 miles | 277 miles |
| City / Highway / Combined | 134 / 117 / 125 MPGe | 123 / 111 / 117 MPGe | 110 / 97 / 104 MPGe |
| Energy use, combined | 27 kWh/100 mi | 29 kWh/100 mi | 32 kWh/100 mi |
| 0–60 mph (Tesla) | 6.5 s | 4.8 s | 3.5 s |
| Curb weight | 4,154 lb | 4,363 lb | 4,398 lb |
| Wheels | 19 or 20 in | 19 or 20 in | 21 in |
| Seats | 5 | up to 7 | 5 |
| Ground clearance | 6.8 in | 6.8 in | 6.2 in |
| Supercharging, 15 minutes | up to 170 miles | up to 163 miles | up to 151 miles |
| Full charge at 240 V (EPA) | 12 hours | 12 hours | 11.8 hours |
Tesla’s own November 2024 lease terms were based on a $44,990 purchase price for the Long Range RWD. We could not confirm Tesla’s figures for the other two versions, and the company changed prices often, so we leave them out rather than guess. Overnight charging on a home wall box covers most driving; if you are new to that, here is how Level 1, Level 2 and DC fast charging differ.
Which 2025 Model Y trim should you buy?
For most people, the Long Range RWD. It has the longest range figure, the best efficiency and the lowest curb weight of the three versions, and it shares the 19- or 20-inch wheels of the AWD car. Its 6.5-second 0–60 claim is the slowest here, but still brisk for a family crossover.
Choose the Long Range AWD if you drive in snow, or if you need the optional third row: it was the only 2025 version Tesla offered with seven seats. Skip the Performance unless speed is the point. It is the quickest, but it has the lowest range rating, 21-inch wheels, the least ground clearance and, per Car and Driver, a lowered suspension. One twist from that magazine’s testing: at 75 mph the Performance went 10 miles further than the AWD car, so on the interstate the EPA gap overstates the difference.
What changed for the 2026 Model Y?
Almost everything you can see or hear. Tesla described the redesign at launch as a new nose with a full-width light bar, a single lighting strip across the tail, acoustic glass, ventilated front seats, a powered recline for the rear seats, an 8-inch screen for rear passengers and a reworked suspension. By Tesla’s figures, road noise fell 22 percent and wind noise 20 percent, and rated range rose about 5 percent on the same battery energy. The EPA ratings bear that out:
| Version | 2025 (EPA) | 2026 (EPA) |
|---|---|---|
| Long Range RWD | 337 miles, 125 MPGe | 357 miles, 134 MPGe |
| Long Range AWD | 311 miles, 117 MPGe | 327 miles, 123 MPGe |
| Performance AWD | 277 miles, 104 MPGe | 306 miles, 105 MPGe |
| Standard RWD | not offered | 321 miles, 138 MPGe (18-in wheels); 303 miles, 131 MPGe (19-in) |
| Standard AWD | not offered | 294 miles, 127 MPGe |
The 2026 lineup also added cheaper Standard versions the 2025 range never had. Going the other way, the 2025 model year had already dropped the short-range rear-drive base car that the 2024 lineup sold with a 260-mile rating.

For a 2025 buyer, that means paying for an older design, and the price should reflect it. The redesign goes after the two most common complaints, noise and ride. Car and Driver found the 2026 quieter inside than before, though it still calls the ride firm.
Should you buy a used 2025 Model Y in 2026?
It can be a sound purchase if the price is right and the paperwork is clean. Four checks first:
- Recalls. NHTSA lists three recalls for the 2025 Model Y: a tire-pressure warning light that could go out between drives (fixed over the air), a circuit-board fault that could blank the rearview camera (a software update, with failed computers replaced), and, filed in May 2026, a certification label that may never have been fitted (Tesla Service installs it). Run the VIN on nhtsa.gov to confirm each one is closed.
- Tax credit. The federal used clean vehicle credit is gone. The IRS says it is not available for vehicles acquired after 30 September 2025, so price the car without it.
- Warranty. Tesla quoted 4 years or 50,000 miles of basic cover and 8 years or 120,000 miles on the battery and drive unit for these cars, so a 2025 should have plenty of battery cover left. Check the in-service date and the odometer.
- Model year. Make sure the car really is a 2025. A light bar across the nose means a 2026, while a 2024 looks the same as a 2025, so go by the title and the VIN, whose tenth character is S for the 2025 model year.
On safety, the 2025 car holds a five-star overall NHTSA rating in both AWD and RWD form, and the IIHS names it a Top Safety Pick+, with several crash results carried over from tests of 2021 and 2022 Model Ys. For running costs against a gas crossover, see our breakdown of the real cost of owning an electric car in 2026. And if you are cross-shopping, the 2025 Mustang Mach-E GT is the obvious rival with a sportier brief.
Sources: EPA fueleconomy.gov ratings for the 2024, 2025 and 2026 Tesla Model Y; NHTSA recall records and 5-Star Safety Ratings for the 2025 and 2026 Model Y; IIHS ratings for the 2025 Model Y; Tesla’s Model Y specification page (archived 23 November 2024) and Tesla, “Introducing the New Model Y” (1 April 2025); IRS pages on the new and previously-owned clean vehicle credits; Car and Driver, MotorTrend and J.D. Power pages for the 2025 and 2026 Model Y. Photos: HJUdall / Wikimedia Commons, CC0; Dllu / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
